Best Crossbow for Deer Hunting – Full Reviews for Whitetail Season

Deer hunting season is right around the corner, which means it’s time to start thinking about your equipment for the upcoming hunt. For many hunters, a crossbow can be an excellent choice of weapon for harvesting whitetails. Crossbows provide the accuracy and power needed to ethically take down deer while being easier to use than traditional archery equipment.

In this blog post, we’ll discuss the key factors to consider when choosing the best crossbow for deer hunting and provide recommendations on some of the top crossbows on the market today. We’ll cover what to look for in draw weight, arrow speed, size and weight, noise and vibration levels, and scope quality.

Additionally, we’ll provide tips on how to properly set up and sight in your new crossbow before hitting the woods. With the right crossbow that fits your needs and skill level, you’ll be ready to have a successful and efficient deer hunting season. So read on to learn what crossbow could be the perfect addition to your deer hunting gear this season.

Quick Recommendation for Best Crossbow for Deer Hunting

• KILLER INSTINCT Boss 405 Crossbow
• Barnett Whitetail Hunter II Crossbow – (Best crossbow for deer hunting under $500)
• Killer Instinct Lethal 405 Crossbow Pro Package
• CenterPoint AXCDH185CK Dusk Hunter 370 Crossbow Package
• CenterPoint Pulse 425 Crossbow (Best hunting crossbow under $1000)
• TenPoint Titan M1 Crossbow (Best crossbows under $1000)  
• Barnett HyperGhost 425 Crossbow

Best Crossbow for Deer Hunting – Our Top 7 Picks

1. KILLER INSTINCT Boss 405 Crossbow

I’ve been searching for the perfect crossbow that balances power, speed, accuracy, and adjustability for the upcoming deer season. After testing numerous models, I’m thoroughly impressed with the performance and features of the KILLER INSTINCT Boss 405 Pro Package. This crossbow lives up to its name as a complete hunting weapon ready for the field. Right out of the box, I could feel the high-quality craftsmanship and solid construction built into this crossbow.

Drawing 405 feet per second, the integrated suppressors make each shot whisper quiet. The adjustable stock fits snugly against my shoulder, providing a customized fit for comfort and stability. The optics and accessories like the rope cocker and carbon bolts maximize functionality. After sighting in the crossbow at various distances, I was blown away by the level of downrange precision this crossbow delivers.

Shots out to 60 yards clustered tightly thanks to the combination of smooth trigger pull, match-grade barrels, and calibrated 4×32 scope. The kinetic energy on impact rivals what many centerfire rifles produce.

Pros:

• Custom-fit adjustable stock
• Whisper quiet with suppressors
• Dialed inaccuracy
• Hard-hitting speed and power
• Complete hunting package

Cons:

• Heavier cocking weight

---

2. Barnett Whitetail Hunter II Crossbow 

As a hunter looking to upgrade to a crossbow this season, I decided on the BARNETT Whitetail Hunter II based on its blend of speed, accuracy, and reliability. As soon as I assembled this crossbow out of the box, I could tell it was thoughtfully engineered for hunters. At just 6.4 pounds, the streamlined design is easy to maneuver in ground blinds and tree stands.

Despite the lightweight, this crossbow still packs a punch with velocities up to 350 fps. After dialing in the optics at the range, I was impressed by how the 16” axle-to-axle length and matching arrow retention system enabled tight downrange grouping. The safety features like the anti-dry-fire trigger provided peace of mind. Within just a few sessions, I became confident in making ethical shots out to 40 yards.

Pros:

• Lightweight and compact
• Smooth, crisp trigger
• Good accuracy when sighted in properly
• Quality accessories included
• Trusted BARNETT brand

Cons:

• Lower power than premium crossbows
• Lubrication required after extensive use

---

3. Killer Instinct Lethal 405 Crossbow Pro Package

The Killer Instinct Lethal 405 has quickly become one of the most popular crossbows for hunters demanding speed, power, and accuracy in a lightweight package ready for all-day endurance. As soon as I assembled this crossbow, the quality craftsmanship was evident through features like the skeletonized stock and adjustable foregrip.

This crossbow wastes no weight while still driving arrows at a blistering 405 fps. The included string suppressors and custom rubber absorbers make each shot whisper quiet. Drawing the Lethal 405 is smooth thanks to the adjustable foregrip that allows you to fine-tune the optimal hand placement. The illuminated scope provides quick target acquisition even at dawn and dusk. After properly sighting in the optics, this crossbow can deliver 2-inch groups out to 60 yards.

Pros:

• Blazing 405 fps speed
• Super lightweight design
• Whisper quiet operation
• Customizable grip improves accuracy
• Premium accessories included

Cons:

• Scope quality could be improved
• Heavier draw weight for some

---

4. CenterPoint AXCDH185CK Dusk Hunter 370 Crossbow Package

The CenterPoint Dusk Hunter 370 has quickly become one of my favorite budget-friendly crossbow packages for deer hunting. Weighing just 7 pounds, this lightweight crossbow is easy to maneuver and carry in the field. The narrow axle-to-axle width makes it ideal for hunting from ground blinds or tree stands.

Despite its compact size, the 370 fps velocity provides more than enough kinetic energy for ethical shots within moderate hunting ranges. The inclusion of features like the anti-dry-fire trigger and automatic safety gives me peace of mind. The CNC machined cam system creates a smooth, consistent shooting cycle.

The machined aluminum riser improves downrange accuracy and limb alignment. Once I dialed in the 4×32 scope, this crossbow consistently delivered 2-3 inch groups out to 40 yards during practice.

Pros:

• Great value for the price
• Lightweight and compact
• Smooth and consistent power stroke
• Reliable safety features
• Capable hunting accuracy

Cons:

• Lower fps than premium models
• Scope quality is just adequate
• Some plastic parts feel cheap

---

5. CenterPoint Pulse 425 Crossbow

As an avid deer hunter, I’m always on the lookout for a crossbow that provides speed, power, and accuracy to take down my prey. The CenterPoint Pulse 425 has quickly become my go-to weapon in the field. Packing a 425 fps velocity and 153-foot pounds of kinetic energy, this crossbow delivers deadly downrange shots. The narrow 12-inch axle-to-axle width when cocked lets me easily maneuver the Pulse 425 in tight blinds and tree stands.

I love how the Whisper Silencing System reduces noise and vibration on release-critical for not spooking wary whitetail. The anti-dry fire and auto safety features give me peace of mind that an accidental discharge won’t happen. After taking the Pulse 425 on multiple deer hunts, I’m convinced it’s one of the best crossbows for deer hunting on the market. The lightweight, compact size makes it easy for me to handle and carry, even on all-day sits.

Yet the performance has the power and velocity I need to take down a deer-sized game. I’ve been consistently impressed with the Pulse 425’s smooth draw cycle and release. My groups are tight thanks to the consistency it provides shot after shot. The dampened sound has allowed me to take multiple shots at deer before they detect me. For hunters like me who demand stealth, power, and accuracy, the CenterPoint Pulse 425 is a clear choice.

Pros:

• Lightning quick 425 fps speed
• Hard-hitting 153 ft-lbs kinetic energy
• Narrow for easy handling in blinds
• Whisper quiet on release
• Safety features for peace of mind

Cons:

• Limited kinetic energy due to power stroke
• A bit heavier than other compact crossbows

---

6. TenPoint Titan M1 Crossbow

The TenPoint Titan M1 crossbow delivers top-tier performance and handling in a value-packed package built for whitetail. This flagship model shoots arrows at up to 370 FPS while maintaining TenPoint’s legendary accuracy. The narrow axle width of 9″ gives hunters excellent maneuverability in ground blinds and tree stands.

Revolutionary VX-5 cams provide an ultra-smooth draw cycle and more powerstroke for deadly downrange speed. At just 6.4 lbs, the Titan M1 is one of TenPoint’s lightest crossbows ever, making it easy to carry on long pursuits. An integrated crank cocking device lets you draw the bow safely and quietly at just 5 lbs of force.

After testing this crossbow extensively, it’s clear the Titan M1 is purpose-built for deer hunting. The lightweight skeletonized stock aids off-hand shooting while a customized comb allows perfect head positioning. Combined with TenPoint’s match-grade T5 trigger, the Titan M1 gives you pinpoint precision on every shot. The included illuminated 3X scope makes ranging and targeting game in dim conditions a breeze. For hunters demanding elite-level accuracy in a value-priced crossbow, the Titan M1 is sure to impress.

Pros:

• 370 FPS velocity
• Lethal downrange power from extended Powerstroke
• Narrow axle width enhances maneuverability
• Just 6.4 lbs for easy carrying
• Built-in cocking mechanism for easy drawing

Cons:

• Limited kinetic energy due to lower draw weight
• Only includes 3 arrow quiver

---

7. Barnett HyperGhost 425 Crossbow

The Barnett HyperGhost 425 brings blistering speed and downrange power to a lightweight, maneuverable hunting package. At 425 FPS with 152 ft-lbs of kinetic energy, this crossbow has the velocity and impact to take down big game. The narrow step-thru design along with Barnett’s single bolt assembly makes the HyperGhost easy to maneuver in tight spaces. I love that it includes Barnett’s TriggerTech trigger for a crisp, clean break on every shot.

The contoured handle and cheekpiece allow me to line up shots comfortably and accurately. After using the HyberGhost 425 extensively for deer season, I’m confident in recommending it to fellow hunters. The included 1.5-5×32 illuminated scope gave me quick target acquisition even at dawn and dusk. My arrow groups were tight thanks to the match-grade accuracy this crossbow provides.

The rope cocking sled allows me to draw the bow safely and quietly on the hunt. At just 7.7 lbs, the lightweight HyperGhost doesn’t weigh me down on long stalks. For hunters who prioritize speed, maneuverability and downrange power, the Barnett HyperGhost 425 is a winner.

Pros:

• Blazing 425 FPS velocity
• 152 ft-lbs kinetic energy for knockdown power
• Narrow design for handling in blinds/treestands
• Match grade TriggerTech trigger
• Lightweight 7.7 lb build

Cons:

• Limited kinetic energy due to lower draw weight
• Cheekpieces may be uncomfortable for some

---

A Comprehensive Guide to Choose the Best Crossbow For Deer Hunting

Hunting whitetail deer with a crossbow can be an extremely rewarding experience. With the right crossbow matched to your skills and needs, you’ll be set up for an ethical, effective, and accurate hunt.

This comprehensive guide will walk you through the key factors to evaluate when selecting the best crossbow for deer hunting.

Weight and Maneuverability

Look for a crossbow designed specifically for hunting applications, which prioritizes a lightweight, compact size between 6 to 7 pounds. Significant weight can make carrying and positioning the bow in tight spaces like ground blinds or treestands difficult and tiring.

The crossbow should feel balanced and maneuverable when raised and drawn to align with your target. An adjustable stock allows you to properly fit the crossbow to your arm length and shooting form.

Optimal Draw Weight

Draw weights for deer hunting crossbows generally range from 150 to 200 pounds. Heavier draw weights in the 175 to the 200-pound range will send arrows downrange at higher velocities, expanding your maximum shooting range.

But heavier draws can also be more strenuous to load and cock. Many hunters find a 175-pound draw weight provides the ideal combination of speed and manageable cocking effort. Match the crossbow weight to your strength and stamina to allow for accurate shot placement.

Power Stroke

The power stroke refers to the linear distance the bowstring travels when cocking the crossbow to its firing position. Longer power strokes between 12 to 14 inches create more kinetic energy to shoot arrows at higher speeds.

Make sure the arrow length is properly matched to the power stroke for optimal downrange accuracy and penetration.

Noise Dampening Ability

The quieter your crossbow, the less likely you’ll spook deer and alert them to your presence. Many crossbows now incorporate noise-dampening technologies like string silencers and padded sling mounts to muffle vibrations and sound.

Auto-engaging safety features allow hunters to decock the bow silently if a shot opportunity is missed.

Scope and Sighting System

A magnified scope in the 3-5x power range helps improve shot accuracy and target visibility. Match the optics to your expected shooting distance – low magnification for close range, higher for longer range shots. A multi-reticle scope with trajectory compensation hashes takes the guesswork out of field adjustments. Quality optics and proper mounting rings optimize your crossbow’s precision.

Cocking Aids

For rapid reloading between shots, a rope cocking device or crank cocking mechanism reduces the effort needed to span the bowstring into the firing position. Cocking aids allow hunters to ethically take follow-up shots when needed and prevent arm fatigue from manual cocking.

Frequently Asked Questions

What scope magnification is best for crossbow deer hunting?

The best scope magnification for crossbow deer hunting is typically 3-5x power. This provides enough magnification to precisely place shots out to 40-50 yards, while still allowing for quickly locating and centering on the target in close-range situations. Avoid highly magnified scopes; it can be hard to find and align on the deer in heavy cover.

How do I choose the best crossbow for deer hunting?

When choosing the best crossbow for deer hunting, key factors to evaluate are weight, draw weight, power stroke, velocity, noise-dampening features, and optics. Look for a lightweight, maneuverable bow between 150-200 lbs draw weight. Check the power stroke matches your arrow length. Speeds of 320+ fps expand the range. Noise dampening is crucial. And a quality 3-5x scope improves accuracy.

How fast should my crossbow arrows travel for deer hunting?

For effective deer hunting, crossbow arrows should travel at minimum speeds of 320-340+ feet per second at impact. This allows for adequate penetration through a deer’s hide and bone structure for ethical and efficient kills. Faster arrow speeds also help offset trajectory drops at longer ranges. Match your arrows’ grain weight to the FPS rating of your crossbow.

What is the ideal draw weight for a crossbow used in deer hunting?

The ideal draw weight for a crossbow used in deer hunting is typically between 150-200 lbs. Draw weights in the 175-200 lb range provide enough kinetic energy for ethical shots on deer out to 40-50 yards. Heavier draws can be hard to manage for extended hunts. Shoot a few different-weight crossbows to find the optimal balance of power versus comfort and control.

What is the best crossbow cocking device for deer hunting?

The best crossbow cocking devices for deer hunting include rope cocking aids, crank cocking mechanisms, and lever pulley systems. These reduce the high effort of spanning the bow string manually. Rope cocker aids are compact and affordable. Crank cockers provide a high mechanical advantage for heavy draw weights. Lever cockers integrate the pulleys seamlessly onto the crossbow.

Conclusion

When it comes to selecting the ideal crossbow for hunting whitetail deer, there are a variety of factors savvy hunters take into account. By considering the critical criteria of draw weight, power stroke, velocity, mass weight, noise-dampening abilities, safety features, and optics quality, you can zero in on the perfect crossbow to match your skills and needs.

While many excellent crossbow options exist today, one simply can’t go wrong choosing a lightweight, fast-shooting bow in the 150 to 200-pound draw weight range, equipped with dampeners and a 3-5x scope. Taking the time to test potential crossbows first-hand gives you the chance to gauge the feel, handling, and accuracy of different models. Investing in a high-quality crossbow designed specifically for hunting, properly matched to your strength and shooting form, will set you up for an ethical, efficient, and exciting hunt.

With the right preparation and equipment, crossbow hunting provides an extremely rewarding way to pursue whitetails and put meat in the freezer. Remember to always put safety first and take the time to practice until you can confidently make a clean, killing shot. Doing your homework will lead you to crossbow success when the moment of truth arrives this deer season.